Inclusive workplaces boost productivity by 30% Learn How
Partner With Us
Flag IN
IN
USA
UK

What if the witness refuses to speak in an Internal Committee inquiry?

Table of Contents

Author

Kelp

witness 1

Problem Statement: 
As per CCTV evidence and the victim’s statements a witness was present when the incident occurred. But the witness feigns ignorance. This witness’s testimony is very crucial to the case. As an IC member, is there any action that can be taken?
 Witnesss Right to silence.
The Constitution of India guarantees every person right against self-incrimination under Article 20 (3): “No person accused of any offence shall be compelled to be a witness against himself”. It is well established that the Right to Silence has been granted to the accused by virtue of the pronouncement in the case of Nandini Sathpathy vs P.L.Dani, no one can forcibly extract statements from the accused, who has the right to keep silent, but only in the court of law. It is not clear if the accused can exercise his right to silence during interrogation by public servants. Interrogation techniques like narco-analysis, brain mapping and lie detection nullify the validity and legitimacy of the Right to Silence. But in 2010, the Supreme court found that narco-analysis, brain mapping and lie detector tests violate Article 20(3).
Reasons for witness to turn hostile or stay silent:
At the workplace, the reasons for a witness to turn hostile may be:

  • Fear of retaliation.
  • Fear of losing their job.
  • Threat by the accused.
  • Lack of awareness of the policy or process.
  • Lack of trust in the committee or management.
  • Absence of Witness Protection.
  • Prolonged trials.

Hostile Witnesses: Judicial Remedy
For a situation like the Jessica Lal case, where witnesses refused to support the prosecution’s case, the committee has suggested the following measures:
1. Holding in-camera proceedings
2. Taking measures to keep identity of witness’s secret
3. Ensuring anonymity
4. Making arrangements to ensure their protection
5. Witnesses should be treated like guests of honour
6. They should be adequately compensated for spending money on travel and accommodation
7. Comfort, convenience and dignity of witness/es while giving their statements in the court of law, should be ensured
In Summary:

  • A Witness can stay silent, if they wish to and cannot be forced. In such cases the, above judicial remedies may be followed to enhance the trust in the witness.
  • A fine can be imposed or action can be taken on the witness, only if the witness says contradicting statements or retracts a statement made.
  • Also, if the witness statement is proved to be intentionally false or malicious, then a strong action can be taken on the witness.

Ref:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_to_silence#India
http://www.legalservicesindia.com/article/article/hostile-witnesses-and-efficacy-of-law-1692-1.html

Recent Posts

Categories

Calendar Icon Events
Close

Event Calendar

MAY 2026

MO
TU
WE
TH
FR
SA
SU
27
28
29
30
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31

Head – Client Relations

Gomathi Venkatasubramanian is a seasoned client relations and strategy leader with over nine years of experience in sales, client engagement, and conflict resolution. As the Head of Client Relations, Gomathi and her team ensure that every Kelp client enjoys excellence in service delivery and engagement.  With her vast product knowledge, Gomathi takes pride in being able to go beyond the call to action and provide innovative solutions and services to clients that align with their people and business goals.

Prior to Kelp, Gomathi worked with organizations across the sales and presales cycles thereby acquiring a deep understanding of the process and how to shift from a sales to a solutions mindset.  That has helped her in honing her unique style in building client relations and trust.

Beyond her professional pursuits, Gomathi enjoys traveling and exploring new destinations, embracing different cultures and perspectives. She also finds solace in Indian music, which serves as a source of relaxation and inspiration.

 

Navneet Chugh

Director & Entrepreneur

Navneet, Managing Partner of Chugh LLP, offers global legal and tax services with 575 employees. An Attorney, CPA, and MBA from USC, he founded SABA and TiE Southern California and serves on multiple boards globally.

Bhaskaran MR

Director & Entrepreneur

Baskaran Rajaraman is an entrepreneur with interests in real estate, healthcare, and eCommerce. He has previously consulted with Krossark, Citrisys, Booz Allen, and Hamilton, and Polaris on BFSI, eCommerce, and logistics.

Manju Manocha

Head - Business Development

Manju, Head of Business Development at Kelp, drives sales strategy and growth. An HR expert with a master’s in Personnel Management, she has worked with Mphasis, BMC, Syntel, and WNS.

Smita Mukharjee

Head – DEI Center of Excellence

Smita is a dynamic and experienced DEI and Learning Consultant with a unique blend of academic expertise and practical application. With an MBA from the University of Mumbai and an M.Phil from the esteemed Tata Institute of Social Sciences, she is currently pursuing a PhD.

Smita brings with her over a decade and a half of experience across both academia and corporate training and has helped shape the learning journeys of professionals across industries. Her expertise spans human behaviour, training and development, research, and organizational diagnostics. Smita’s research has been showcased at prestigious institutions, including IIM Indore, IIM Bangalore, IIM Trichy, and Nirma University..

Passionate about fostering diversity and inclusion, Smita brings an engaging approach to training, blending research-driven insights with interactive methodologies. Beyond her professional commitments, she enjoys exploring new cultures and perspectives through travel, always seeking to broaden her understanding of the world.

Shalu Salwan

Chief Operating Officer

Shalu, an MBA from ISB, leads operations and product development at Kelp, focusing on efficiency and impact. Passionate about L&D, DEI, and PoSH, she thrives on adventure—whether scaling mountains or exploring the ocean.

Elango R

Global Leader

Elango, Global CHRO and Business Head at MphasiS, grew the company from $12 million to over a billion. He led key integrations, integrated CSR practices, and has held leadership roles at Raheja Group, UB Group, and Bank of America.

Rangan Mohan

Veteran Executive Coach

Rangan Mohan, an executive coach with 30 years of experience, has held CEO roles at MphasiS and Hinduja Global Solutions. A graduate of Madras University and IIM Ahmedabad, he is now a director and consultant.

Deepa Padmanaban

Head – Learning Solutions and PoSH Center of Excellence

Deepa, an MBA and Certified PoSH trainer, excels in client experience and HR. At Kelp, she fosters inclusivity through collaboration. Passionate about singing and voice artistry, she also announces for All India Radio.